As equipment, insurance, technology, and compliance costs climb, recovery fees remain stuck in the past. Is the industry finally ready to demand change?
GUEST EDITORIAL
Recently I saw a contract from 2007, the client will remain unnamed. The fees they were offering in 2007 where Involuntary rate of $350 Voluntary rate of $175 and a “Standard close fee of $75”. They also in that same contract noted that they were reducing storage from 10 free days and now requiring 15 days free. The date on the contract was December 10th, 2007. A close fee that is almost unheard of today.
Out of fairness I researched just the cost of a light duty wrecker in 2007 the average retail of a light duty wrecker ranged from $55,000-$75,000 depending on many factors.
Today the average cost of a light duty Wrecker ranges from $105,000-$140,000. Source Google.
That is almost double for just 1 piece of equipment that is required to repossess a piece of collateral for the lender. Have your Rates almost doubled since 2007 to offset the cost just for the wrecker?
Now let’s talk about technology and compliance.
LPR was not a household name in 2007 while it was in the market it was not what it is today. And that LPR technology comes at a cost. The equipment, the labor, the fuel there is expense there, but it would seem the clients want to pay a reduced fee for any LPR recovery.
Why do we spend more to recover their collateral and get paid less? All the while someone else has access to our scans that we spent countless dollars to obtain.
Compliance, while we thought we were doing all we could in 2007 to be compliant, 20 years later the model has changed and there is tremendous effort placed on compliance. And for good reasons.
I tried to research the increase in litigation relating to our industry and the increase of said litigation since 2007. Because federal and state courts do not track “repossession lawsuits” as a single standalone statistical category, there is no single aggregate number measuring how much they have grown since 2007.
However, court data, regulatory enforcement actions, and consumer advocacy reports show that repossession-related litigation has increased significantly in both volume and legal complexity since the 2007–2009 Great Recession.
Not to get too far off topic lets get back to the contract from 2007.
Inflation over the 19-year span has been 62.78%. Who in our industry has seen a 50% increase in rates in the last 19 years?
Absolutely no one.
The question I cannot answer is why? Why have our rates been stagnant for 20 years?
There is a magnitude of reasons, someone will do it cheaper, the clients look for those people. If you are a business owner, you have mouths to feed you have employees and families that you are responsible for and you have bills to pay so, you keep your head down and you do the best you can and the clients continue to demand more for less.
How do we get change?
I sent an email to every CEO or president of a forwarding company that I had contact info for last week with a link to the article posted in the CU repossession, “Is Trucking the Canary in the Repo Industry’s Coal Mine?” and a message that we need change, and we need them to lead the change.
The only response I received was from a senior vendor rep at on company telling me they welcome “open dialogue with all associations”.
Open Dialogue does not get the ball moving it just sits and goes back and forth. I hear it all the time from vendor reps at varying forwarding companies that they are “Agent Friendly” and that they go to bat for the agent.
Well as much as I want to throw rocks. They are not the ones that are able to lead change and explain to the client that stagnant rates are killing the industry. That is over their heads.
And guess what, the forwarders have the same fight that we do in that someone will do it cheaper. That is what keeps the rates down, most national clients use forwarders whether we like that or not it is fact.
And forwarder “A” really needs a feather in their hat, so they agree to “do it cheaper” and in return are promised more volume. Then they come to the agent and say “take it or leave it I’ll call the guy down the street.”
I am not telling anyone how to run their business. Some take it because they need it, others take it because they fear missing out. We all have our reasons.
I have heard many in the industry say well don’t work for the forwarders. And for some that may be a valid option but for others depending on the market they service, and the business model they have molded their business around it may not be an option.
I have no specific gripes about working for the forwarders, but feel that we need them to start working for the agent as well.
How do we go forward, how do we get the forwarders to quit driving prices down and taking away more with every new contract?
They agree to no storage so they can be promised more work. And again, the agents are told to “take it or leave it.”
Without change, the industry is in trouble.
I suggested to the forwarders in the message that I sent to them that they should create their own association! That while individually they would be laughed at if they demanded a 50% increase in rates, but unified, they could tell the client take it or leave it.
How do we lead the industry that has agreed to stagnant rates for 20 years into a prosperous future? Isn’t that the dream as a business owner, a prosperous future?
Without Change is the Risk worth the Reward? – Without Change is the Risk worth the Reward? – Without Change is the Risk worth the Reward?
Darrell Parsons
President
US Recovery Services
Eagle Group XX





More Stories
The Repossession Industry Is Eating Its Own
Twelve Years, Seventy-Five Dollars
The LPR Arms Race: How Many Cameras Are Enough?
The Cost of Collecting LPR Data Has Gone Up. Why Hasn’t the Pay?
WHEN IS ENOUGH, ENOUGH? A Question Worth Asking Across the Repossession Industry
Three Million Repossessions: A New Measure of America’s Recovery Industry